300 E 4Th St

Originally constructed in 1888 as a rectory and later expanded for residential use, this five-story boutique co-op occupies a conspicuous corner of Avenue C and East 4th Street in the East Village. The masonry exterior features brownstone trim, gabled rooflines and pointed-arch entrances that reflect its late 19th-century institutional origins; an elevator was added during conversion to residential use. Eleven primarily one-bedroom units occupy the building, many with lofted mezzanines, exposed brick, reclaimed-wood built-ins, high ceilings (often 12–16 feet), and individualized layouts that recall the structure’s former life as a clergy house and school. Interior finishes vary by unit but commonly include hardwood floors, skylights, soaking tubs, eat-in kitchens with custom cabinetry, pantry space, recessed lighting and decorative chandeliers. Common spaces cater to practical urban living: a landscaped shared roof deck plus individual private rooftop gardens for select apartments, a laundry room, bike storage, keyless video intercom tied to residents’ phones, and on-site superintendent services. The building allows pets and maintains a flexible subletting policy (rentals permitted after two years) with a modest flip tax structure. Street-level convenience is strong—Citi Bike is one block away and Tompkins Square Park, neighborhood restaurants, galleries, and music venues are within easy walking distance, contributing to an address that blends historic character with contemporary amenity comforts.