For Sale
Single family home for sale at 5544 Sugartown Rd, Great Valley, NY 14741 | MLS# R1719936 | Listing updated on 2026-10-05
Photo 1 of Single family home for sale at 5544 Sugartown Rd, Great Valley, NY 14741 | MLS# R1719936 | Listing updated on 2026-10-05
Photo 2 of Single family home for sale at 5544 Sugartown Rd, Great Valley, NY 14741 | MLS# R1719936 | Listing updated on 2026-10-05
Photo 3 of Single family home for sale at 5544 Sugartown Rd, Great Valley, NY 14741 | MLS# R1719936 | Listing updated on 2026-10-05
Photo 4 of Single family home for sale at 5544 Sugartown Rd, Great Valley, NY 14741 | MLS# R1719936 | Listing updated on 2026-10-05
38+
Beds Icon

Street View

$479,900

Monthly Est:$2,389

  • Beds Icon4 Beds
  • Beds Icon
    3 Baths
  • Beds Icon2,156sqft

5544 Sugartown Rd, Great Valley, NY 14741

$2,389/moEst:

Get Pre-Approved

  • Single Family Residence

  • Built in 1940

  • $-- HOA

  • 0.49 acre lot

  • $223/sq.ft

Description

**FULLY FURNISHED** Welcome to 5544 Sugartown Rd, your fully updated and turn-key retreat in the heart of Great Valley. Currently used as a successful short term rental, this fully updated 4-bedroom, 3 full bath home has been thoughtfully renovated throughout, combining comfort, style, and functionality-easily accommodating an astonishing 16 guests. Recent improvements just this past year include a new well tank, new water softener system, new hot water tank, and a 4-stage filtration system for well water-providing peace of mind for years to come. The home also features newly renovated bathrooms and a brand-new hot tub, creating the ideal space to relax after a day outdoors or to boost income potential for short term stays. Extensive upgrades and improvements have been made throughout this home over the years, too many to fully capture in one description. With all of the hand-crafted furnishings and necessities included, this property is truly move-in ready or primed for immediate short-term rental use. Located just minutes from Ellicottville’s ski country, Holiday Valley, and year-round attractions including shopping and dining, it’s perfectly positioned for both personal enjoyment and income potential. Whether you’re looking for a weekend getaway or a cash-cow investment property, this is the perfect option. VR Pricing, Seller will entertain offers from $479,900-$529,900

  • Houzeo last checked: 10 minutes ago
  • Listing updated: October 5, 2026 at 5:38 pm
  • Listing Provided by: Mikayla Seiberg (716) 245-3406 DRE #10401353661 | Realty One Group Empower (716) 899-4663
  • Source: New York State Alliance of MLSs, Buffalo-NY | MLS#: R1719936 New York State Alliance of MLSs, Buffalo-NY

Property Details

  • Status

    Active

  • Type

    Single Family Residence

  • No. of Stories

    2

  • County

    Cattaraugus County

  • City

    Great Valley

  • Neighborhood

    --

  • Year Built

    1940

  • HOA Fees

    -

  • Finished Area

    2,156 sqft

  • Lot Size

    0.49 acre lot

  • Basement Area

    - sqft

  • MLS Name

    New York State Alliance of MLSs, Buffalo

  • MLS Number

    R1719936

  • MLS Status

    Active

  • Days on Market

    20

  • Cumulative Days on Market

    170

Continue Your Journey in App

Find your dream home, receive real-time updates, and many more!

Location

Facts & Features

Rooms

  • Bedrooms & bathrooms

    Bedrooms: 4

    Bathrooms: 3

Interior

  • Cooling

    Ductless, Other, See Remarks

  • Heating

    Ductless, Propane, Other, See Remarks, Baseboard

  • Flooring

    Other, See Remarks

  • Exterior Features

    Blacktop Driveway, Propane Tank Owned

  • Appliances

    Appliances Negotiable, Dryer, Dishwasher, Gas Cooktop, Propane Water Heater, Refrigerator, Washer

  • Interior Features

    Separate Formal Dining Room, Eat In Kitchen, Other, See Remarks, Bedroom On Main Level

  • Sewer

    Septic Tank

Construction

  • Year Built

    Year Built: 1940

  • Home type

    Single Family Residence

  • Construction Materials

    Other, See Remarks

  • Architectural Style

    Other, See Remarks

  • Property Condition

    Resale

  • Foundation Details

    Other, See Remarks

Utilities & Energy

  • Water Source

    Well

  • Basement

    Partial

  • Parking Features

    Attached, Garage

Other Features

  • Lot Features

    Irregular Lot, Other, See Remarks

Price History

DateEventPrice

10/05/2026

Source: mls_logoNew York State Alliance of MLSs, Buffalo-NY #R1719936

Listed for Sale

$479,900

$223/sqft

10/05/2026

Source: mls_logoNew York State Alliance of MLSs, Buffalo-NY #R1719936

Off Market

$479,900 -7.69%

$223/sqft

06/16/2026

Source: mls_logoNew York State Alliance of MLSs, Buffalo-NY #R1673813

Listing Removed

$519,900

$241/sqft

06/16/2026

Source: mls_logoNew York State Alliance of MLSs, Buffalo-NY #R1673813

Off Market

$519,900 -1.89%

$241/sqft

04/15/2026

Source: mls_logoNew York State Alliance of MLSs, Buffalo-NY #R1673813

Listed for Sale

$529,900 +9.26%

$246/sqft

Show more

Nearby Homes

Based on data from the New York State Alliance of MLSs (CNYIS, Inc., UNYREIS and WNYREIS) through Oct 26, 2026, 11:00AM.. All information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use. It may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. The data is deemed reliable by is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS. This website may not include listings or property addresses of sellers who have directed their listing brokers to withhold their listing or their property address from display on the Internet. All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. © 2026 the New York State Alliance of MLSs. All Rights Reserved.

Advertising Broker: Derek Greene | The Greene Realty Group