1846 Muttontown Rd, Oyster Bay, NY 11791

Description

A Rare Idyllic Muttontown Estate + Barn Offering Privacy, Lifestyle & Endless Opportunities
Nestled on 2 beautifully landscaped acres directly across from the breathtaking Muttontown Preserve, this meticulously maintained retreat presents a rare opportunity to enjoy the best of Long Island's Gold Coast lifestyle. Combining privacy, open space, and an exceptional location, this property offers the tranquility of country living while remaining just minutes from shopping, dining, top-rated schools, golf courses, equestrian facilities, the Long Island Rail Road, major parkways, and an easy commute to New York City.
Designed for today's lifestyle, the spacious 5-bedroom, 4.5-bath residence features a thoughtful, functional open floor plan with generously sized living spaces, two full kitchens, and a private “in-law” suite with private entrance—ideal for multi-generational living, extended guests, a home office, or income-producing opportunities.
The grounds are even more impressive, creating a true private retreat. The in-ground pool with Spa, the expansive lawn with built in soccer field and charming treehouse are perfect for outdoor entertaining. The mature plantings that have been lovingly cultivated over the years, provide exceptional beauty and year-round privacy.
For equestrian enthusiasts, the property is a standout. A grandfathered three-stall horse barn with its own separate driveway entrance and adjoining paddock offers a unique opportunity for private horse ownership in one of Long Island's most desirable communities. ( or an income producing opportunity to board )
This home has been meticulously cared for and offers valuable recent improvements, including:
New roof (within the last five years)
New hot water heater (within the last five years)
Brand-new central air conditioning system (2026)
Brand-new boiler (2026)
While cosmetic updates would allow a new owner to personalize the interiors, the home's outstanding layout, exceptional maintenance, and significant infrastructure upgrades provide an incredible foundation for creating a truly spectacular estate.
Whether you're searching for a compound, an equestrian retreat, or a private sanctuary with room to grow, this remarkable property offers a rare combination of space, versatility, and location that is seldom available.