
Rexburg has held a place among the safest cities in Idaho for several consecutive years according to FBI data, with a violent crime rate well below the national average. It sits in Madison County in eastern Idaho, anchored by a strong civic culture and high homeownership that keeps residential streets calm and well-connected. Low population density outside the city center, minimal commercial crime exposure, and a police department that maintains consistent visibility all contribute to the record. Families and retirees looking for a low-incident community in eastern Idaho find that Rexburg delivers on that in measurable terms.
Rexburg has held a place among the safest cities in Idaho for several consecutive years according to FBI data, with a violent crime rate well below the national average. It sits in Madison County in eastern Idaho, anchored by a st...
Personal Safety : 96
Property Safety : 92
Community Safety : 79
$350,000
Median Home Rent
$1,200

Priest River sits in Bonner County along the Pend Oreille River. The chance of becoming a victim of violent crime here is 1 in 927, well below the national figure. A small, rural population, high homeownership, and limited commercial foot traffic all contribute to a residential environment that stays consistently calm. The Priest River Police Department maintains a staffing ratio above both the Idaho and national averages. Buyers who want scenic North Idaho living with a manageable safety profile find that Priest River checks their boxes.
Priest River sits in Bonner County along the Pend Oreille River. The chance of becoming a victim of violent crime here is 1 in 927, well below the national figure. A small, rural population, high homeownership, and limited commerc...
Personal Safety : 100
Property Safety : 88
Community Safety : 59
$385,000
Median Home Rent
$1,140

Rigby is the seat of Jefferson County and keeps violent crime well below both Idaho and national averages, with FBI data placing its violent crime rate roughly 80% below the national figure. The overall crime rate sits nearly 59% below the national average. High homeownership, low-density streets, and a close agricultural community identity create a residential environment that has stayed consistently stable. Families and retirees drawn to small-town eastern Idaho life find Rigby offers genuine safety figures to back up the quiet feel of the community.
Rigby is the seat of Jefferson County and keeps violent crime well below both Idaho and national averages, with FBI data placing its violent crime rate roughly 80% below the national figure. The overall crime rate sits nearly 59% ...
Personal Safety : 90
Property Safety : 89
Community Safety : 55
$290,000
Median Home Rent
$1,516

Sandpoint sits on Lake Pend Oreille in Bonner County and offers a scenic residential environment in one of North Idaho's most established small cities. The overall community feel is one that long-term residents describe as safe and familiar. High homeownership in established areas and a community that stays engaged in local civic life help maintain neighborhood stability. Buyers drawn to lakefront North Idaho living will find Sandpoint's residential areas generally calm on a day-to-day basis.
Sandpoint sits on Lake Pend Oreille in Bonner County and offers a scenic residential environment in one of North Idaho's most established small cities. The overall community feel is one that long-term residents describe as safe an...
Personal Safety : 95
Property Safety : 77
Community Safety : 51
$592,500
Median Home Rent
$1,995

Spirit Lake keeps things simple. Low population density, minimal commercial activity, and a tight residential character shaped by the lake community it has always been naturally limit crime exposure across the town. Kootenai County law enforcement covers the area with reliable consistency. For families looking to step back from the pace of larger Panhandle cities without giving up a sense of community, Spirit Lake offers a residential environment where the incident counts stay low and the neighbors stay familiar.
Spirit Lake keeps things simple. Low population density, minimal commercial activity, and a tight residential character shaped by the lake community it has always been naturally limit crime exposure across the town. Kootenai Count...
Personal Safety : 82
Property Safety : 91
Community Safety : 39
$499,900
Median Home Rent
$1,000

Few Kootenai County cities can point to year-over-year decreases in both violent and property crime the way Rathdrum can. The Rathdrum Police Department has built that record through sustained community effort rather than circumstance. Low-density residential streets, high homeownership, and a settled neighborhood feel all reinforce what the data shows. Families and those relocating from larger Northwest cities find it safe here within comfortable reach of Coeur d'Alene's broader amenities and services.
Few Kootenai County cities can point to year-over-year decreases in both violent and property crime the way Rathdrum can. The Rathdrum Police Department has built that record through sustained community effort rather than circumst...
Personal Safety : 81
Property Safety : 86
Community Safety : 62
$504,000
Median Home Rent
$2,195

Shelley sits in Bingham County about ten miles south of Idaho Falls and consistently ranks among the safest areas to live in Idaho according to FBI data and SafeWise safety rankings. Violent crime runs well below the national average, and the overall community feel is one shaped by high homeownership and a stable, long-established agricultural identity. Low population density and limited commercial activity keep incident counts low across residential areas. Families seeking a safe, affordable small-town environment within easy reach of Idaho Falls employment and services find Shelley a reliable and practical choice.
Shelley sits in Bingham County about ten miles south of Idaho Falls and consistently ranks among the safest areas to live in Idaho according to FBI data and SafeWise safety rankings. Violent crime runs well below the national aver...
Personal Safety : 76
Property Safety : 86
Community Safety : 56
$493,500
Median Home Rent
$1,125

Kellogg sits in Shoshone County in the Silver Valley and carries a small-town residential character shaped by its mining history and outdoor recreation identity. Population density is low, commercial activity is concentrated and manageable, and residential neighborhoods stay largely removed from the foot traffic of busier areas. High homeownership and long-term resident stability give neighborhoods a settled feel that tends to support lower incident environments. Families and retirees drawn to Silver Valley living find Kellogg's residential areas provide a quieter daily experience than larger Idaho cities.
Kellogg sits in Shoshone County in the Silver Valley and carries a small-town residential character shaped by its mining history and outdoor recreation identity. Population density is low, commercial activity is concentrated and m...
Personal Safety : 73
Property Safety : 94
Community Safety : 25
Median Home Price
$270,000
Median Home Rent
$1,300

Bonners Ferry is the seat of Boundary County in Idaho's far northern Panhandle, with a small, rural population and a tight community identity that shapes daily residential life. The Bonners Ferry Police Department and Boundary County Sheriff's Office provide consistent law enforcement coverage for the area. High homeownership and a community where residents know their neighbors well add an informal layer of accountability. Buyers looking for a rural North Idaho community away from larger urban centers find Bonners Ferry fits that profile.
Bonners Ferry is the seat of Boundary County in Idaho's far northern Panhandle, with a small, rural population and a tight community identity that shapes daily residential life. The Bonners Ferry Police Department and Boundary Cou...
Personal Safety : 61
Property Safety : 91
Community Safety : 43
Median Home Price
$454,500
Median Home Rent
$1,300

Post Falls keeps violent crime below both the Idaho state average and the national average according to FBI data, a meaningful distinction for a city of its size and growth rate. Daily violent crime rates are less than half the national average, and the overall crime rate sits well below the national average. Solid schools, ample parks, and a strong local employment base add practical value beyond the safety numbers. Families and young professionals relocating to the Spokane-Coeur d'Alene corridor regularly land in Post Falls.
Post Falls keeps violent crime below both the Idaho state average and the national average according to FBI data, a meaningful distinction for a city of its size and growth rate. Daily violent crime rates are less than half the na...
Personal Safety : 75
Property Safety : 77
Community Safety : 44
$549,000
Median Home Rent
$2,000
Transparent & data-driven
Each city is scored against the national average across three weighted categories, built entirely from FBI NIBRS crime data spanning 18 offense categories. Every metric is converted to a per-capita rate and a common 0–100 scale, so no single offense can dominate — and a city served by a non-reporting agency is never treated as crime-free.
Homicide, rape, robbery, aggravated assault, kidnapping & human trafficking vs. the national rate.
Burglary, larceny, motor vehicle theft, arson & theft from buildings or vehicles vs. the national rate.
Simple assault, sex offenses, stolen property, vandalism, weapon & drug violations — the tiebreaker.
Recalculated as each new annual NIBRS reporting year is released · agency-to-city mappings refresh quarterly.
Important Legal Disclosures
MLS Disclaimers
The market analysis provided on this page is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial, investment, or legal advice. Data is sourced from public records, industry reports, and third-party providers, and while Houzeo strives for accuracy, we make no guarantees regarding the completeness, accuracy, or timeliness of the information presented.
All estimates, projections, and historical data are based on statistical models and should not be relied upon as predictions of future market conditions. Past performance is not indicative of future results, and real estate market conditions may change due to various economic and regulatory factors. Users are responsible for conducting their own due diligence before making any real estate or financial decisions. Houzeo is not liable for any decisions or actions taken based on the information provided. Any unauthorized use, duplication, or distribution of the data may violate copyright laws and result in legal consequences. Certain information, tools and services on this page may be powered by third-party vendors. Houzeo does not control or guarantee the accuracy, reliability, or functionality of such third-party services.