65 E 96Th St

Built in 1924 and occupying a prewar limestone façade on Carnegie Hill, The Gatsby Condominium is a 16-story, small-footprint full-service building with just 14 three-bedroom residences and a handful of larger classic five- and six-room layouts. Architecture and interiors emphasize traditional prewar proportions: high beamed ceilings, herringbone and oak hardwood floors, crown moldings, marble fireplaces and generous foyers. Apartments feature formal dining rooms, eat-in chef’s kitchens with premium appliances, abundant built-in storage and walk-in closets; many homes include multiple exposures, large picture windows, and restored original details alongside modern updates such as central air and in-unit washers and dryers. The building’s common areas are understated and service-focused, offering a staffed 24-hour doorman, live-in superintendent, elevator access, a fitness room, central laundry, bike storage and private storage lockers. Pet-friendly policies and an on-site resident manager support flexible household types. Located one block from Central Park and Museum Mile, the building sits amid Carnegie Hill’s museums, brownstones, schools, transit connections and neighborhood shopping, delivering a refined Upper East Side lifestyle centered on proximity to green space, cultural institutions and established residential streets.