For Sale
Open House
Single family home for sale at 2 Bayview Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11965 | MLS# 1059229 | Listing updated on 2026-10-08
Photo 1 of Single family home for sale at 2 Bayview Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11965 | MLS# 1059229 | Listing updated on 2026-10-08
Photo 2 of Single family home for sale at 2 Bayview Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11965 | MLS# 1059229 | Listing updated on 2026-10-08
Photo 3 of Single family home for sale at 2 Bayview Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11965 | MLS# 1059229 | Listing updated on 2026-10-08
Photo 4 of Single family home for sale at 2 Bayview Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11965 | MLS# 1059229 | Listing updated on 2026-10-08
36+
Beds Icon

Street View

$3,895,000

Monthly Est:$19,387

  • Beds Icon4 Beds
  • Beds Icon
    7 Baths
  • Beds Icon5,377sqft

2 Bayview Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11965

$19,387/moEst:

Get Pre-Approved

  • Single Family Residence

  • Built in 2018

  • $815.17/mo HOA

  • 1 acre lot

  • $724/sq.ft

Description

Welcome to 2 Bayview Ave, a stunning modern home nestled in the serene, walkable streets of Shelter Island Heights, NY. This corner lot property boasts an expansive acre of bucolic land, offering a tranquil escape.

The exterior of the home features large front and back porches with ample overhangs for three season comfort. Mahogany decking, porcelain tiles, integrated speakers and overhead fans enhance the enjoyment of picturesque surroundings. The raised backyard is a very private sanctuary of its own with a 16 x 40 gunite pool, a cozy cabana and lush greenery, creating an oasis for relaxation or entertaining.

Step inside to a spacious open floor plan accentuated by 1
0-foot ceilings and a stunning 15ft x 20ft custom window wall that bathes the home in natural southern light. Wide-plank light oak flooring and a cohesive palette of contrasting trim elements evoke a Nordic design language throughout. The custom kitchen is a chef's dream, complete with an oversized quartz island, copious storage, a Thermador appliance suite, and a convenient walk-in pantry. The home is designed for comfortable everyday living and effortless entertaining.

Down a windowed hall and separated from the entertaining areas of the home, the primary suite on the main level is a haven of comfort, featuring a large walk-in closet and a luxurious bathroom with double sinks on a floating vanity, a private toilet room and multi-fixture wet room. The main level also houses a convenient laundry room, a powder room, extra closets and a versatile bonus space with its own rear-patio entrance and an attached full bathroom.

Upstairs, a cozy, windowed loft space overlooks the main living area. A bright hall joins three additional en-suite bedrooms, including a junior primary suite. Each bath boasts fine fixtures and marble work. The finished lower level provides valuable additional space for recreation, a home gym, media room or overflowing living with a full bathroom and walk-out level access to a private covered patio offers endless potential for customization.

The property also includes a 3-car garage – a true rarity in Shelter Island Heights – elegantly situated below the sightlines of the home’s main living areas, thus preserving views of the beautifully landscaped surroundings. A secondary driveway that serves the garage features custom board-formed retaining walls, exquisite plantings and warm landscape lighting that add to the property's striking visual impression.
2 Bayview Ave. is more than just a home; it's a lifestyle. It's a place where modern luxury meets the tranquility of nature.

  • Houzeo last checked: 6 hours ago
  • Listing updated: October 8, 2026 at 1:37 pm
  • Listing Provided by: Christine M. Beckwith (631) 354-8100 | Douglas Elliman Real Estate (631) 354-8100
  • Source: OneKey MLS-NY | MLS#: 1059229 OneKey MLS-NY

Property Details

  • Status

    Active

  • Type

    Single Family Residence

  • No. of Stories

    -

  • County

    Suffolk County

  • City

    Shelter Island

  • Neighborhood

    --

  • Year Built

    2018

  • HOA Fees

    $815.17/mo

  • Finished Area

    5,377 sqft

  • Lot Size

    1 acre lot

  • Basement Area

    - sqft

  • MLS Name

    OneKey MLS

  • MLS Number

    1059229

  • MLS Status

    Active

  • Days on Market

    1

Open House

Continue Your Journey in App

Find your dream home, receive real-time updates, and many more!

Location

HOA Management

Shelter Island Heights Property Owners Corp

HOA Fees

$9,782/ Annually

Amenities

Amenities and services may be covered by one or multiple associations and service providers.

Sewer Sewer

Water Water

Other Other

Disclaimer: Amenities are based on third-party information and may vary; buyers must independently verify all amenities, as information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Facts & Features

Rooms

  • Bedrooms & bathrooms

    Bedrooms: 4

    Bathrooms: 7

Interior

  • Sewer

    Public Sewer

  • Cooling

    Central Air

  • Flooring

    Hardwood

  • Interior Features

    First Floor Bedroom, First Floor Full Bath, Cathedral Ceiling(s), Ceiling Fan(s), Chandelier, Chefs Kitchen, Double Vanity, Eat In Kitchen, Entrance Foyer, Galley Type Kitchen, High Ceilings, Kitchen Island, Marble Counters, Open Floorplan, Open Kitchen, Pantry, Primary Bathroom, Master Downstairs, Quartz/quartzite Counters, Recessed Lighting, Smart Thermostat, Soaking Tub, Sound System, Speakers, Storage, Walk In Closet(s)

  • Heating

    Forced Air, Propane

  • Appliances

    Convection Oven, Dishwasher, Dryer, Exhaust Fan, Freezer, Gas Range, Microwave, Refrigerator, Stainless Steel Appliance(s), Washer, Tankless Water Heater

Construction

  • Year Built

    Year Built: 2018

  • Home type

    Single Family Residence

  • Construction Materials

    Wood Siding

  • Architectural Style

    Modern

Utilities & Energy

  • Basement

    Full, Partially Finished

  • Water Source

    Public

  • Parking Features

    Private

  • Utilities

    Cable Connected, Electricity Connected, Phone Available, Propane, Sewer Connected, Water Connected

  • Pool Features

    In Ground

  • Association Amenities

    Other

Other Features

  • Lot Features

    Corner Lot

  • Patio And Porch Features

    Covered, Deck, Patio, Porch

Price History

DateEventPrice

10/08/2026

Source: mls_logoOneKey MLS-NY #KEY1059229

Listed for Sale

$3,895,000

$724/sqft

Nearby Homes

Based on information from OneKey MLS, through Oct 08, 2026, 11:01AM. IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. © 2026 OneKey® MLS. All rights reserved.

Advertising Broker: Derek Greene | The Greene Realty Group