$250,000
Bedrooms: 2Bds
Bathrooms: 2Ba
Area: 952sqft
Manufactured home for sale
Joanne Kane Gigantiello
$250,000
Bedrooms: 2Bds
Bathrooms: 2Ba
Area: 952sqft
Manufactured home for sale
Joanne Kane Gigantiello
$900,000
Views: 7
Bedrooms: 2Bds
Bathrooms: 1Ba
Area: 936sqft
Sale Pending
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
$2,495,000
Views: 1
Bedrooms: 3Bds
Bathrooms: 3Ba
Area: 2,228sqft
Single family home for sale
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
$1,250,000
Views: 16
Bedrooms: 2Bds
Bathrooms: 2Ba
Area: 1,464sqft
Single family home for sale
Rustycap O Inc
$1,275,000
Views: 15
Bedrooms: 3Bds
Bathrooms: 3Ba
Area: 1,564sqft
Sale Pending
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
$985,000
Views: 18
Bedrooms: 3Bds
Bathrooms: 2Ba
Area: 1,266sqft
Single family home for sale
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
$1,275,000
Views: 14
Bedrooms: 4Bds
Bathrooms: 2Ba
Area: 2,074sqft
Single family home for sale
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
$3,895,000
Views: 8
Bedrooms: 4Bds
Bathrooms: 7Ba
Area: 5,377sqft
Single family home for sale
Douglas Elliman Real Estate
$3,290,000
Views: 14
Bedrooms: 5Bds
Bathrooms: 5Ba
Area: 6,106sqft
Mansion for sale
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
$2,200,000
Views: 23
Bedrooms: 4Bds
Bathrooms: 3Ba
Area: 1,994sqft
Single family home for sale
Douglas Elliman Real Estate
$5,000,000
Views: 21
Bedrooms: 4Bds
Bathrooms: 6Ba
Area: 4,000sqft
Single family home for sale
Douglas Elliman Real Estate
$2,690,000
Views: 1
Bedrooms: 4Bds
Bathrooms: 3Ba
Area: 2,289sqft
Single family home for sale
World Prop Intl Sea To Sky
$2,995,000
Views: 17
Bedrooms: 3Bds
Bathrooms: 3Ba
Area: 2,300sqft
Single family home for sale
Century 21 Excelsior Realty
$2,239,000
Views: 16
Bedrooms: 6Bds
Bathrooms: 4Ba
Area: 3,413sqft
Single family home for sale
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Brown Harris Stevens Hamptons
$4,250,000
Views: 15
Bedrooms: 4Bds
Bathrooms: 6Ba
Area: 3,500sqft
Single family home for sale
Corcoran
$4,995,000
Views: 15
Bedrooms: 5Bds
Bathrooms: 7Ba
Area: 5,535sqft
Mansion for sale
Douglas Elliman Real Estate
$1,850,000
Views: 12
Bedrooms: 4Bds
Bathrooms: 3Ba
Area: 2,600sqft
Single family home for sale
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
$2,199,000
Views: 17
Bedrooms: 5Bds
Bathrooms: 4Ba
Area: 2,642sqft
Single family home for sale
Douglas Elliman Real Estate
$3,850,000
Views: 16
Bedrooms: 4Bds
Bathrooms: 6Ba
Area: 3,985sqft
Single family home for sale
Douglas Elliman Real Estate
$2,700,000
Views: 16
Bedrooms: 6Bds
Bathrooms: 3Ba
Area: 5,900sqft
Mansion for sale
Compass Greater Ny Llc
$575,000
Views: 12
Bedrooms: --Bds
Bathrooms: --Ba
Area: 25,265sqft lot
Sale Pending
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
$1,595,000
Views: 12
Bedrooms: --Bds
Bathrooms: --Ba
Area: 27,007sqft lot
Land for sale
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Don't miss out on new listings — and get instant email alerts!
Find your dream home, receive real-time updates, and many more!
Shelter Island is a buyer's market right now. Homes are sitting on the market for 160 days on average. With 16 months of supply, there's less pressure to rush and more room to negotiate on price and terms.
Buyer's Market
160
23
In Mar 2026 · YoY
Current rate · YoY
30-Year Fixed
30-yr fixed rate 7.28% · Data as of Mar 2026 · Source: Houzeo Research.
View Full Shelter Island Market Report23
Homes Available
$ 1,180,000
Median List Price
160 Days
Avg on Market