$2,200,000
13
4Bds
3Ba
1,994sqft
Single family home for sale
Douglas Elliman Real Estate
4 Bedroom Homes for Sale in Shelter Island, NY
8 Homes for Sale
Sort by:Newest Listings
$5,000,000
12
4Bds
6Ba
4,000sqft
Single family home for sale
Douglas Elliman Real Estate
$4,250,000
8
4Bds
6Ba
3,500sqft
Single family home for sale
Corcoran
$1,495,000
7
4Bds
2Ba
2,074sqft
Single family home for sale
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Price Drop: $260K
$2,690,000
8
4Bds
3Ba
2,289sqft
Single family home for sale
World Prop Intl Sea To Sky
$3,999,000
9
4Bds
7Ba
5,500sqft
Single family home for sale
Atlas Sales Realty
$1,850,000
5
4Bds
3Ba
2,600sqft
Single family home for sale
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
$3,850,000
7
4Bds
6Ba
3,985sqft
Single family home for sale
Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Don't miss out on new listings — and get instant email alerts!
- Real Estate
- Homes For Sale
- New York
- Shelter Island
- 4-Bedroom Homes
Do Real Estate on the Go!
Find your dream home, receive real-time updates, and many more!
Shelter Island, NY Housing Market Overview
Shelter Island is a buyer's market right now. Homes are sitting on the market for 160 days on average. With 16 months of supply, there's less pressure to rush and more room to negotiate on price and terms.
Status
Buyer's Market
Days on Market
160
Inventory
16
Sep 2021Jun 2024Mar 2026
Median Home Price
$1,180,000Down 0.37%
In Mar 2026 · YoY
Sep 2021Jun 2024Mar 2026
Mortgage Rates 30-Yr Fixed
6.23%Down 0.58%
Current rate · YoY
Loan Type
30-Year Fixed
Housing Supply
- Homes For Sale
- 16 Down 0.27%
- Newly Listed Homes
- 9 Up 1.25%
- Months of Supply
- 16 Up 5.00%
Housing Demand
- Homes Sold
- 1 Down 0.00%
- Sale-to-List Ratio
- 94.4% Down 2.79%
- Homes Sold Above List
- 0% Down 50.00%
30-yr fixed rate 6.23% · Data as of Mar 2026 · Source: Houzeo Research.
View Full Shelter Island Market ReportNo. of Homes
Prices
No. of Homes
Based on information from OneKey MLS, through Oct 7, 2026, 6:01 AM. IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. © 2026 OneKey® MLS. All rights reserved.
Click to see all homes
Satellite
Shelter Island, NY Housing Market
8
Homes Available
$ 1,180,000
Median List Price
160 Days
Avg on Market
Do Real Estate on the Go!
For Sale
Price
Beds & Baths
Home Type (5)
Filters
