Pending
Sale Pending at 4 Bayview Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11965 | MLS# 1045616 | Listing updated on 2026-09-29
Photo 1 of Sale Pending at 4 Bayview Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11965 | MLS# 1045616 | Listing updated on 2026-09-29
Photo 2 of Sale Pending at 4 Bayview Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11965 | MLS# 1045616 | Listing updated on 2026-09-29
Photo 3 of Sale Pending at 4 Bayview Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11965 | MLS# 1045616 | Listing updated on 2026-09-29
Photo 4 of Sale Pending at 4 Bayview Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11965 | MLS# 1045616 | Listing updated on 2026-09-29
16+
Beds Icon

Street View

$1,999,999

Monthly Est:$9,955

  • Beds Icon6 Beds
  • Beds Icon
    6 Baths
  • Beds Icon6,098sqft

4 Bayview Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11965

$9,955/moEst:

Get Pre-Approved

  • Single Family Residence

  • Built in 2001

  • $821.08/mo HOA

  • 41,806 sqft lot

  • $328/sq.ft

Description

Welcome to 4 Bayview Avenue, a remarkable residence nestled in the historic heart of Shelter Island Heights. This expansive property, designed with the art of entertaining in mind, offers a generous six bedrooms and five and a half bathrooms, providing an abundance of space for comfortable living. Upon entering, you'll be welcomed by an array of inviting sitting areas spread throughout the main house, each offering a unique setting for relaxation or socializing. The fully finished lower level, complete with direct access to the pool and backyard, adds a layer of versatility to the living space. This home is equipped with a variety of desirable features such as central air, a cozy fireplace, and a dedicated office space, ensuring your every comfort and convenience is met. The private guest quarters serve as a separate haven for visitors, enhancing the overall accommodation. The outdoor space is a haven of peace and privacy, with beautifully landscaped grounds and mature trees. The newly installed expansive mahogany decks, adorning both the main house and guest house, offer the perfect backdrop for outdoor gatherings and soaking in the surrounding natural beauty. The property also invites you to partake in community amenities such as a beach club and tennis, allowing you to fully embrace the joys of coastal living. A two-car garage with radiant heat flooring adds to the property's convenience, while the heated gunite pool and outdoor shower offer additional luxuries. With a vast area of approximately 6,098 square feet, this home is designed to cater to a variety of lifestyle needs. This exceptional property in Shelter Island Heights is waiting for you to make it your own. Don't miss this opportunity. Schedule a private viewing.

  • Houzeo last checked: 2 minutes ago
  • Listing updated: September 29, 2026 at 7:36 pm
  • Listing Provided by: Christine M. Beckwith (631) 354-8100 | Douglas Elliman Real Estate (631) 354-8100
  • Source: OneKey MLS-NY | MLS#: 1045616 OneKey MLS-NY

Property Details

  • Status

    Pending

  • Type

    Single Family Residence

  • No. of Stories

    -

  • County

    Suffolk County

  • City

    Shelter Island

  • Neighborhood

    --

  • Year Built

    2001

  • HOA Fees

    $821.08/mo

  • Finished Area

    6,098 sqft

  • Lot Size

    41,806 sqft lot

  • Basement Area

    - sqft

  • MLS Name

    OneKey MLS

  • MLS Number

    1045616

  • MLS Status

    Pending

  • Days on Market

    36

  • Cumulative Days on Market

    28

Continue Your Journey in App

Find your dream home, receive real-time updates, and many more!

Location

HOA Management

Shelter Island Heights Property Owners Corp

HOA Fees

$9,853/ Annually

Amenities

Amenities and services may be covered by one or multiple associations and service providers.

Water Water

Club House Club House

Sewer Sewer

Other Other

Disclaimer: Amenities are based on third-party information and may vary; buyers must independently verify all amenities, as information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Facts & Features

Rooms

  • Bedrooms & bathrooms

    Bedrooms: 6

    Bathrooms: 6

Interior

  • Exterior Features

    Balcony, Gas Grill, Rain Gutters

  • Sewer

    Public Sewer

  • Heating

    Oil, Radiant Floor

  • Appliances

    Convection Oven, Dishwasher, Dryer, Electric Range, Electric Water Heater, Exhaust Fan, Freezer, Microwave, Refrigerator, Stainless Steel Appliance(s), Washer

  • Flooring

    Hardwood, Tile

  • Interior Features

    First Floor Bedroom, First Floor Full Bath, Ceiling Fan(s), Entrance Foyer, Formal Dining, Galley Type Kitchen, High Ceilings, Kitchen Island, Original Details, Pantry, Primary Bathroom, Quartz/quartzite Counters, Recessed Lighting, Soaking Tub, Storage, Walk Through Kitchen, Walk In Closet(s), Washer/dryer Hookup

  • Cooling

    Central Air

Construction

  • Year Built

    Year Built: 2001

  • Home type

    Single Family Residence

  • Construction Materials

    Frame, Shake Siding, Stone

  • Architectural Style

    Colonial

Utilities & Energy

  • Basement

    Finished, Full, Walk Out Access

  • Pool Features

    In Ground

  • Utilities

    Electricity Connected, Propane, Sewer Connected, Water Connected

  • Parking Features

    Driveway, Garage

  • Association Amenities

    Clubhouse, Other

  • Water Source

    Public

Price History

DateEventPrice

09/29/2026

Source: mls_logoOneKey MLS-NY #KEY1045616

Pending

$1,999,999

$328/sqft

09/01/2026

Source: mls_logoOneKey MLS-NY #KEY1045616

Listed for Sale

$1,999,999

$328/sqft

Nearby Homes

Based on information from OneKey MLS, through Oct 08, 2026, 06:46AM. IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. © 2026 OneKey® MLS. All rights reserved.

Advertising Broker: Derek Greene | The Greene Realty Group