Hot
$375,677
15
5Bds
3Ba
2,736sqft
Sale Pending
MLS ID #22115967, Compass Indiana, Llc
5 Bedroom Homes for Sale in New Bethel, Indianapolis, IN
17 Homes for Sale
Sort by:Newest Listings
Hot
New Construction
$559,990
7
5Bds
3Ba
3,617sqft
Single family home for sale
MLS ID #22121688, M/I Homes Of Indiana, L.P.
New Construction
$399,633
7
5Bds
3Ba
2,736sqft
Single family home for sale
MLS ID #22127941, Compass Indiana, Llc
Hot
$400,000
19
5Bds
4Ba
2,178sqft
Single family home for sale
MLS ID #22125822, Fathom Realty
Price Drop: $15K
$393,020
11
5Bds
3Ba
3,054sqft
Sale Pending
MLS ID #22122802, Compass Indiana, Llc
Price Drop: $33.45KNew Construction
$401,345
5
5Bds
4Ba
3,054sqft
Single family home for sale
MLS ID #22127943, Compass Indiana, Llc
Price Drop: $10K
3D Tour
$499,990
5
5Bds
3Ba
3,477sqft
Sale Pending
MLS ID #22099047, M/I Homes Of Indiana, L.P.
3D Tour
$585,000
5Bds
4Ba
3,698sqft
Single family home for sale
MLS ID #22123165, Keller Williams Indy Metro Ne
$487,000
10
5Bds
4Ba
3,513sqft
Single family home for sale
MLS ID #22098432, Real Broker, Llc
HotPrice Drop: $38K
$365,490
17
5Bds
3Ba
2,367sqft
Single family home for sale
MLS ID #22126591, Compass Indiana, Llc
New Construction
$428,390
4
5Bds
4Ba
3,174sqft
Sale Pending
MLS ID #22115973, Compass Indiana, Llc
3D Tour
$525,000
10
5Bds
4Ba
4,205sqft
Single family home for sale
MLS ID #22125905, @Properties
New Construction
$369,371
10
5Bds
3Ba
2,247sqft
Sale Pending
MLS ID #22118349, Compass Indiana, Llc
$495,000
5
5Bds
3Ba
3,469sqft
Single family home for sale
MLS ID #22086841, Century 21 Scheetz
$382,000
11
5Bds
3Ba
2,760sqft
Single family home for sale
MLS ID #22121503, Wemy Realtor
$395,000
5
5Bds
4Ba
3,143sqft
Single family home for sale
MLS ID #22106604, Urban Dream Realty Llc
New Construction
$395,485
5
5Bds
3Ba
2,367sqft
Single family home for sale
MLS ID #22099050, Compass Indiana, Llc
Don't miss out on new listings — and get instant email alerts!
- Real Estate
- Homes For Sale
- Indiana
- Indianapolis
- New Bethel
- 5-Bedroom Homes
Do Real Estate on the Go!
Find your dream home, receive real-time updates, and many more!
New Bethel, IN Housing Market Overview
New Bethel in Indianapolis is a balanced market, giving buyers and sellers room to negotiate. Homes are selling for 98.28% of asking price and averaging 54 days on the market, so you can make decisions without the pressure of a highly competitive market.
Status
Balanced Market
Days on Market
54
Inventory
33
Sep 2021Mar 2024Feb 2026
Median Home Price
$492,499Up 0.39%
In Feb 2026 · YoY
Sep 2021Feb 2024Feb 2026
Mortgage Rates 30-Yr Fixed
6.23%Down 0.58%
Current rate · YoY
Loan Type
30-Year Fixed
Housing Supply
- Homes For Sale
- 33 Up 0.50%
- Newly Listed Homes
- 16 Up 0.14%
- Months of Supply
- 3.3 Down 0.00%
Housing Demand
- Homes Sold
- 10 Down 0.00%
- Sale-to-List Ratio
- 98.3% Up 1.06%
- Homes Sold Above List
- 10% Up 10.00%
30-yr fixed rate 6.23% · Data as of Feb 2026 · Source: Houzeo Research.
View Full New Bethel Market ReportNew Bethel Ranks #12 in Indianapolis, IN
46
Homes
$1,250
Rental Prices
$492.5K
Median Home Price
No. of Homes
Prices
No. of Homes
No. of Homes
Based on information from MIBOR REALTOR® Association through Oct 9, 2026, 4:00 AM. The Broker Listing Cooperative® listing service's Listing information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the Broker Listing Cooperative® listing service. All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker or Broker Listing Cooperative listing service. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information.. All Rights Reserved. © 2026 MIBOR REALTOR® Association.
Click to see all homes
Satellite
New Bethel, Indianapolis, IN Housing Market
17
Homes Available
$ 492,499
Median List Price
54 Days
Avg on Market
Do Real Estate on the Go!
For Sale
Price
Beds & Baths
Home Type (5)
Filters
