3D Tour
$3,290,000
7
5Bds
5Ba
6,106sqft
Mansion for sale
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Single Family Homes for Sale in Shelter Island Heights, NY
16 Homes for Sale
Sort by:Newest Listings
3D Tour
$1,999,999
1
6Bds
6Ba
6,098sqft
Sale Pending
Douglas Elliman Real Estate
$2,200,000
13
4Bds
3Ba
1,994sqft
Single family home for sale
Douglas Elliman Real Estate
$5,000,000
12
4Bds
6Ba
4,000sqft
Single family home for sale
Douglas Elliman Real Estate
$4,995,000
7
5Bds
7Ba
5,535sqft
Mansion for sale
Douglas Elliman Real Estate
$4,250,000
8
4Bds
6Ba
3,500sqft
Single family home for sale
Corcoran
$1,495,000
7
4Bds
2Ba
2,074sqft
Single family home for sale
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
$1,275,000
8
3Bds
3Ba
1,564sqft
Single family home for sale
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
3D Tour
$2,239,000
10
6Bds
4Ba
3,413sqft
Single family home for sale
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Price Drop: $260K
$2,690,000
8
4Bds
3Ba
2,289sqft
Single family home for sale
World Prop Intl Sea To Sky
$2,995,000
7
3Bds
3Ba
2,300sqft
Single family home for sale
Century 21 Excelsior Realty
3D Tour
$2,800,000
12
5Bds
5Ba
4,200sqft
Single family home for sale
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
$3,999,000
9
4Bds
7Ba
5,500sqft
Single family home for sale
Atlas Sales Realty
$3,850,000
7
4Bds
6Ba
3,985sqft
Single family home for sale
Douglas Elliman Real Estate
$2,700,000
7
6Bds
3Ba
5,900sqft
Mansion for sale
Compass Greater Ny Llc
$4,800,000
13
5Bds
4Ba
3,325sqft
Single family home for sale
Serhant East End Llc
Don't miss out on new listings — and get instant email alerts!
- Real Estate
- Homes For Sale
- New York
- Shelter Island Heights
- Single-Family Homes
Do Real Estate on the Go!
Find your dream home, receive real-time updates, and many more!
Shelter Island Heights, NY Housing Market Overview
Shelter Island Heights is a buyer's market right now. Homes are sitting on the market for 160 days on average. With 9 months of supply, there's less pressure to rush and more room to negotiate on price and terms.
Status
Buyer's Market
Days on Market
160
Inventory
9
Sep 2021May 2024Mar 2026
Median Home Price
$1,180,000Down 0.00%
In Mar 2026 · YoY
Sep 2021May 2024Mar 2026
Mortgage Rates 30-Yr Fixed
6.23%Down 0.58%
Current rate · YoY
Loan Type
30-Year Fixed
Housing Supply
- Homes For Sale
- 9 Down 0.00%
- Newly Listed Homes
- 7 Down 0.00%
- Months of Supply
- 9 Down 0.00%
Housing Demand
- Homes Sold
- 1 Down 0.00%
- Sale-to-List Ratio
- 94.4% Down 0.00%
- Homes Sold Above List
- 0% Down 0.00%
30-yr fixed rate 6.23% · Data as of Mar 2026 · Source: Houzeo Research.
View Full Shelter Island Heights Market ReportNo. of Homes
No. of Homes
Based on information from OneKey MLS, through Oct 7, 2026, 6:01 AM. IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed. © 2026 OneKey® MLS. All rights reserved.
Click to see all homes
Satellite
Shelter Island Heights, NY Housing Market
16
Homes Available
$ 1,180,000
Median List Price
160 Days
Avg on Market
Do Real Estate on the Go!
For Sale
Price
Beds & Baths
Home Type (1)
Filters
