4.2
Editor's Rating2.7
User Rating (3 Reviews)Andrew the Home Buyer is a real estate investment company based in Arizona. They provide cash offers and purchase homes quickly. Many sellers seek their offers to avoid repairs, long closing timelines, and hefty agent fees.
Pros
Cons
Andrew the Home Buyer is a cash home-buying company that operates in Utah, Colorado, Nevada, and Arizona. Moreover, they purchase homes for cash as-is, so you can skip the hassle of repairs and showings.
However, there is a trade-off. Like most cash buyers, Andrew the Home Buyer typically extends non-negotiable offers that are below the Fair Market Value (FMV). The sale may be convenient, but you might get a single offer of only 50% to 70% of your home’s worth.
No, not for most home sellers. While Andrew the Home Buyer promises quick cash offers and a simple selling process, several customer reviews raise concerns about their pricing, transparency, and service availability.
Here’s a breakdown of these drawbacks:
- Below-Market Cash Offers: Several sellers reported receiving offers significantly below their home’s market value. Like many cash buyers, Andrew the Home Buyer may offer around 50% to 70% of your home’s fair market value, which can leave you with far less than you’d earn on the open market.
- Offer Changes Before Closing: Homeowners alleged that the final purchase price was reduced after the initial offer, forcing them to either accept less money or restart the selling process.
- Limited Service Area: Andrew the Home Buyer operates only in Arizona, Nevada, Utah, and Colorado. If your property is outside these states, you’ll need to consider another cash home buyer.
- Questionable Marketing Claims: The company advertises that they can beat competing cash offers. However some sellers claimed their offer was actually the lowest they received after comparing multiple buyers.
My suggestion: Compare Andrew the Home Buyer with a cash marketplace that let you reviews multiple competing offers instead of accepting just one. This gives you a better chance of maximizing your sale price while still enjoying a fast, hassle-free closing.
Key Takeaways
- Andrew the Home Buyer is a regional cash buyer that helps you sell your property quickly, as-is, and without repairs or traditional listings.
- Average Rating: 4.6-star rating from a total of 1,084 reviews found on Google and BBB.
- Andrew the Home Buyer Pros: Quick cash offers, zero repair costs, fast closing, and clear communication from agents.
- Andrew the Home Buyer Cons: Low-ball offers, limited coverage, misleading advertisements, and reduction in value.
- Andrew the Home Buyer Coverage: Operates in Arizona, Colorado, Nevada, Utah, and a few more key markets.
- Andrew the Home Buyer Alternatives: Houzeo Cash Offers, Opendoor, and HomeVestors.
Is Andrew the Home Buyer Legit?
Yes, Andrew the Home Buyer LLC is a legitimate cash buyer. Additionally, they are rated A- by the Better Business Bureau. We also found seller reviews on Andrew the Home Buyer on many credible sites.
Their brick-and-mortar office is headquartered in Chandler, Arizona. However, as per their website, they also help out homeowners from Colorado, Florida, and Nevada.
Andrew Draayer and Kyle Wyloge own Andrew the Home Buyer. They established the company in 2015.
Andrew the Home Buyer Reviews
On Google, Andrew the Home Buyer has a 4.7-star rating based on 1,051 reviews. Meanwhile, their BBB rating is 4.6 stars based on 33 reviews.
| Website | Rating | Review Count |
|---|---|---|
| BBB |  | 41 |
 | 874 |
We analyzed 1,000+ reviews of Andrew the Home Buyer and found common positive themes, such as:
However, complaints mentioned:
Andrew the Home Buyer Praises
✅ Stress-free home sale and efficient service
Many sellers who had never sought a cash offer before found it easy to work with Andrew the Home Buyer. Most positive reviews highlighted that the company made sure to make the selling process smooth and stress-free. For example, Deanna G shared:
Andrew The Home Buyer is great at what he does. He and Ryan did exactly what they promised. I found them to be honest, caring and compassionate. The offer was fair and everything went smoothly. Plus I didn’t have to empty out the house, which was a big relief for me. I definitely recommend Andrew the Home Buyer!
Source: Google
✅ Convenient, on-your-terms closing timeline
Homeowners found working with Andrew the Home Buyer very convenient. As per their website, the seller decides the home inspection date and closing timeline. Many reviews show that the company does, in fact accommodate the sellers’ personal schedules. Seller Steve Gress reviewed:
Service is wonderful Jim was really flexible with me in my schedule which is not easy to do. I really appreciate the professionalism very Personable guy wasn’t high pressure at all. It was actually a wonderful experience. I’ve never used this kind of service before but pretty happy so far. I’ll be letting you know soon about your offer.
Source: Google
✅ No rush to vacate with one-month move-out timeline
A lot of positive reviews mention that Andrew the Home Buyer allowed the sellers to stay in their sold homes for a month. This grace period helped them to smoothly relocate to their new homes. For instance, Duane and Kelly Nelson mentioned:
Our experience with Andrew the Home Buyer was awesome. We were under contract with another investor and they canceled 2 weeks later for a made up reason. Andrew the Home Buyer originally gave us a offer, which we did not take. After the cancelation, we called Andrew and asked if his offer was still in play. They immediately said yes and they took care of us without any issues. Everyone we worked with was honest and followed through on every step. Bottom line is we closed today on our house and we get to stay 30 days to do a few things on our new place. Once again, Thank You Andrew and group.
Source: Google
Andrew the Home Buyer Complaints
❌ Discounted cash offers for homes in comparison to market value
Sellers complained that Andrew the Home Buyer’s cash offers were below market value. Many of them also advised other homeowners to consider exploring more options rather than accepting this company’s discounted offers. For example, Chandler Banan shared:
Made an offer 250k below value, home ended up selling for 200k above his offer. Before accepting a low offer consider alternative home-buying companies or waiting. This company focuses on recouping the Super Bowl advertising expenses and pointless expensive upgrades to the home rather than fair value.
Source: Google
❌ Misleading advertising and allegedly false marketing
Homeowners shared that contrary to what Andrew the Home Buyer’s advertisements claim, they do not buy every house as-is. Some also said that their offer was the lowest compared to other cash buyers. However, their website says that they can beat any offers in the market. One Seller, Oz Usmc, shared:
This guy doesn’t buy ALL and ANY house. Three years ago he called me and said my house was too upscale for him to even make an offer. FALSE MARKETING. STAY AWAY
Source: Google
❌ Unprofessional representatives and service quality
Some homeowners were dissatisfied with Andrew the Home Buyer’s representatives. Negative reviews of their agents highlight a lack of knowledge and unprofessional behaviour. For instance, seller Courtney McAtee said:
Had an appointment set up with an agent to come view my house. I sent a confirmation email and the reply was “yup”. The response didn’t leave me feeling too great about the meeting. Well, the meeting didn’t even happen because the morning of I get a call telling me their ridiculous lowball offer and things they would have to do to my house BEFORE even seeing it. Stated because of “age”. So anyone with an older house they clearly don’t have the time to actually view your house and give it a proper offer so don’t waste your time.
Source: Google
Pros and Cons of Andrew the Home Buyer
We analyzed numerous reviews of Andrew the Home Buyer and explored their company policies. Here’s what you might like and dislike about the cash buyer.
✅ Pros
- Quick Cash Offers: Andrew the Home Buyer usually make a cash offer immediately after the home inspection. Like seller Tim Osgood, you can also get a cash offer within 30 minutes of the assessment.
- Save on Repair Cost: Andrew the Home Buyer buys houses as they are, which can help you save thousands. You don’t need to repair, renovate, or upgrade your home, and can sell your house as is.
- Fast Closing: Andrew the Home Buyer can close the deal in as little as 7 days. Additionally, you can stay in your home rent-free for up to 30 days.
- Clear Communication From Agents: Multiple sellers like Kris Clarkson praised Andrew the Home Buyer’s agents for being transparent about the selling process and suggesting better options.
❌ Cons
- Low Ball Offers: Some sellers have reported that the offers are unfairly less than the market value. You might get an offer 50% to 70% less than your home’s worth, like Mik Johnson.
- Limited Coverage: Andrew the Home Buyer extends their service in only Arizona, Nevada, Utah, and Colorado. If you are a resident of any other state, then you will have to explore other options.
- Misleading Advertisements: Andrew the Home Buyer’s advertisements promise that they will make a cash offer that beats other offers. However, Austin Howe said the company made the lowest offer among the three cash buyers they contacted.
- Reduction in Offer Value: In some cases, it is seen that the team backed off from the initially promised value right before closing.
🌍 Andrew the Home Buyer Coverage
As per their website, Andrew the Home Buyer offers services in four states: Utah, Arizona, Colorado, and Nevada. However, as per a few news articles, you can also receive their offers if you are a resident of Florida or South Carolina.
No, there aren’t any specific Andrew the Home Buyer reviews from Arizona on Google. Seller feedback on all their different offices are grouped together rather than separated by state.
Yes, Andrew the Home Buyer extends their services to Colorado.
How Does Andrew the Home Buyer Work?
- Submit Your Property Details: You need to provide property details to the company either via phone or a form on their website- andrewthehomebuyer.com.
- Get Your Property Inspected: A member of the team visits your property to inspect its condition.
- Review the Cash Offer: Based on the inspection, they extend a cash offer on the spot or within a day. However, you are under no obligation to accept it.
- Close the Sale: If you accept the offer, the sale can be closed within 7 days.
Types of Property Andrew the Home Buyer Purchases
You can get a cash offer from Andrew the Home Buyer even if your property is:
- At risk of foreclosure
- In need of repairs or upgrades
- Inherited
- Occupied by tenants
- Damaged in flood/ fire/ natural disaster
- Built after 1980
No, Andrew the Home Buyer does not buy mobile homes. Although their website does not mention this specifically, our research shows that they typically buy single-family properties.
How Much Does Andrew the Home Buyer Pay?
Andrew the Home Buyer claims to beat any other cash offer in the market. However, reviews suggest that they generally pay about 50% to 70% of the property’s FMV. This range aligns with typical industry practices as most cash home buyers offer below market value.
So if your property’s Fair Market Value is $400,000, you can expect an offer between $200,000 and $280,000. However, the exact offer depends on the condition of your property. The more repairs your property has, the lower the value you will get.
Andrew the Home Buyer Competitors
We evaluated various real estate companies on the metrics of features such as profit, home condition, and coverage. Our research led us to Houzeo Cash Offers, Opendoor, and HomeVestors as top options.
We conducted a comparative analysis to identify Andrew the Home Buyer’s top competitors based on key factors like profit, home condition, and coverage. We aim to provide a fair and data-driven comparison.
- Market Comparison: We evaluated different types of home-selling solutions, including cash buyers, real estate platforms, and iBuyers to ensure a well-rounded comparison.
- Consumer Feedback Review: We analyzed seller reviews to understand satisfaction levels and common concerns across platforms.
- Selection Criteria: We chose the competitors based on how they differ from Andrew the Home Buyer’s model, to ensure a balanced mix of alternatives.
1. Andrew the Home Buyer vs. Houzeo Cash Offers
Andrew the Home Buyer gives you a direct cash offer after reviewing your property. Since you are dealing with one buyer, you do not get multiple options to compare. If the offer doesn’t meet your expectations, you will need to decline it and seek out other buyers.
Houzeo Cash Offers puts your property in front of multiple vetted local and national cash buyers. You can compare multiple offers and choose the one that provides the best value, with some offers potentially reaching 100% of your home’s market value.
Houzeo Cash Offers provides nationwide coverage, with closings possible in as little as 7 days. You get the speed of a cash sale while retaining the advantage of buyer competition.
| Parameters | MarketPro HomeBuyers | Houzeo Cash Offers |
|---|---|---|
| Sale Price | 50% to 70% of FMV | Up to 100% of FMV |
| Customer Rating | 4.5 stars (847 reviews) | 4.9 stars (11,300+ reviews) |
| Closing Timeline | 7 days | 7 days |
| Coverage | 7 states | Nationwide |
| Multiple Offers | ❌ | ✅ |
| Scope for Negotiation | ❌ | ✅ |
| Highest and Best Offer | ❌ | ✅ |
2. Andrew the Home Buyer vs. Opendoor
Andrew the Home Buyer provides fast cash offers for homes in any condition. Plus to cover the repairs, they typically pay only 50% to 70% of the market value.
Opendoor, on the other hand, is an iBuyer that purchases homes in good to excellent condition. However, they don’t provide 100% of your home’s worth either. On top of a 5% service fee, they might give you only 80% of your property’s value.
3. Andrew the Home Buyer vs. HomeVestors
Andrew the Home Buyer buys distressed properties directly from sellers in only four states. Their offers are often below market value, and their service area is limited.
Meanwhile, HomeVestors operates nationwide. They also buy homes as-is with fast cash offers, but pricing and service quality can vary by local franchise.
Cash Home Buyer Companies Near Me
Like Andrew the Home Buyer, there are other cash companies in different states. You can check the region-wise and state-wise cash companies near you for multiple offers.
Other Options You Should Consider
- Sell With a Flat Fee MLS Service: Flat Fee MLS companies list your home on the MLS for an upfront fee. This way, you can ensure that your home gets exposure to buyers and major real estate platforms without paying agent commission.
- Sell FSBO: For Sale By Owner websites help you list and sell a house yourself. This allows you to save thousands in agent commissions. Many FSBO websites will also help you with the paperwork.
- Sell Through a Realtor: Traditional Realtors list your property on the MLS and help you at every step of home selling. However, you have to pay them 3% of the home’s sale price for this convenience.
- Sell Through Discount Realtors: Discount real estate brokers reduce their commissions to offer affordable services. Their commission varies between 1% and 2.5%. However, they won’t provide you with full-service assistance at this discounted fee.
Should You Sell to Andrew the Home Buyer?
Yes, you can consider Andrew the Home Buyer if you value convenience over profit. They might help you with a quick and hassle-free selling process. However, you can expect to receive a non-negotiable offer, which may be 50% to 70% of your home’s FMV.
For a better deal, consider selling your home with a cash buyer marketplace. This gives your property wider exposure and lets you compare offers from multiple cash buyers. This way, you have more options and a better chance of getting your home’s full value.
We conducted thorough research on reviews for Andrew the Home Buyer to provide an unbiased and fact-based analysis. Our research compiled data on real customer experiences from credible sources. To maintain accuracy, the methodology included:
- Varied Reviews: We gathered reviews of their multiple establishments from Google and BBB to ensure credibility.
- Qualitative Analysis: We analyzed reviews to identify common issues, discern themes, and gauge overall customer sentiment.
- Objective Insights: To highlight both pros and cons, we summarized all the reviews and offered neutral insights.
Resend Code
Reviews
(3 Reviews)
Brian Scott
Verified Reviewer
Peggy and Con Slusher
Verified Reviewer
3rd Mar 2024
I was very pleased with Adrew the homebuyer and recommend his company.
Juan Motay
Verified Reviewer
7th Dec 2023
Put of curiosity, my friend called and inquired how much Andrew’s company would give me for for my house. Online sites state $380k-$420. An employee from Andrew’s company offered $300K. What a ripoff! Sounds like they take advantage of people in need. AVOID this business!
15th May 2026
Don’t trust these people, they will low ball you and bait and switch their offer at the end…the guys who run this run it like a frat house