Table of Contents

6 min read Jan 29, 2024

Cream City Home Buyers Reviews: The Review You NEED to Read

Logo

Cream City Home Buyer purchases homes as is in Milwaukee. They don't have strict eligibility criteria for the homes they buy and even purchase distressed houses.

Editor’s Rating

4.9

User Rating

0
(0 Reviews)

Write a review

Pros

  • Cream City Home Buyer makes cash offers in 24 to 48 hours
  • They have a quick and flexible closing timeline so you can move out at your convenience

Cons

  • Cream City Home Buyers extends offers that are just 50% to 70% of your home's FMV
  • This cash buyer has a limited coverage area

Cream City Home Buyers is a Milwaukee real estate company that pays cash for homes. They have a flexible closing timeline that helps sellers who want to move out of their houses quickly.

However, this cash buyer may give you a lowball cash offer that is just 50% to 70% of your property’s value.

Instead, we recommend listing and selling your home on a cash buyer marketplace like Houzeo.com. Via the MLS, Houzeo gets you exposure to hundreds of local and national investors. You could attract multiple cash offers, and probably even sell for more than 100% of your property’s fair market value.

Let’s look at Cream City Home Buyers reviews and alternatives to see if you can get a better deal for your home.

Key Takeaways

  • Pros: Cream City Home Buyers purchases distressed properties in any condition. Unlike iBuyers, they don’t have strict eligibility criteria when purchasing homes.
  • Cons: This cash buyer has a limited coverage area, operating primarily in Milwaukee. Further you may lose around 30% to 50% of your property’s value.
  • Our Take: We don’t recommend Cream City Home Buyers. Instead, list your home on a cash buyer marketplace like Houzeo to get 100% of your property’s Fair Market Value. Compare Houzeo vs. Cream City Home Buyers.

What is Cream City Home Buyers?

Cream City Home Buyers is a traditional “We Buy Houses for Cash” that operates in Milwaukee. They buy distressed houses for cash at a discount, renovate them, and then sell them for a profit.

If you’re in urgent need of money or need to move out quickly, this cash buyer can close on your property within two weeks.

What Types of Properties Does Cream City Home Buyers Purchase?

Cream City Home Buyers purchases all kinds of homes at a steep discount from distressed sellers. Some of these houses include:

When compared to other cash home buyers, you may be robbed of a huge chunk of money with Cream City Home Buyers.

To avoid such a possibility, list on the MLS with a flat fee company like Houzeo and compare multiple offers from cash companies and iBuyers alike.

    👉 IMPORTANT: Review local housing sales data and determine the Fair Market Value of your property before requesting a cash offer from Cream City Home Buyers.

Cream City Home Buyers vs. Houzeo

Selling to Cream City Home Buyers seems hassle-free. But you pay for this convenience by selling your home at a reduced price.

On the other hand, an MLS listing with Houzeo’s Gold plan equips you with advanced technology to call for the highest and best offers. You can also counter offers to help you get a deal closer to your expectations.

Cream City Home BuyersHouzeo
Sale Price50% to 70% of FMVUp to 100% of FMV
Customer Rating5 stars (33 reviews)4.9 stars (4,523 reviews)
Closing Timeline7 to 30 days2 to 60 days
Fees$379
Closing Costs1% to 3% Closing Costs
Scope for Negotiation
Repair Costs

» Houzeo Reviews: Still not convinced? Read what customers have to say about Houzeo.

Cream City Home Buyers: Pros and Cons

Cream City Home Buyers is a convenient option for sellers who need cash fast. However, their pros and cons paint a clearer picture:

Cream City Home Buyers Pros

Cash home buyers have certain advantages over traditional home-selling processes. Let’s see how Cream City Home Buyers matches up to these expectations.

  • Buy As Is Houses: This “We Buy Homes Fast” company purchases homes as is. So, even if your property is facing foreclosure or needs heavy repairs, you will get a cash offer.
  • Quick Closing: Cream City Home Buyers reviews say they close in as little as two weeks. However, their timeline is flexible, and they can close on a date suitable to you.

Cream City Home Buyers Cons

Cream City Home Buyers complaints reflect the following disadvantages of the company:

  • Lowball Cash Offers: Cream City Home Buyers views your house as an investment opportunity. So, your offer price may be much lower than the market price of your property.
  • Little to No Scope for Negotiation: With cash home buyers like Cream City Home Buyers, you may not have room to negotiate your cash offer. If you still want to try your luck, ensure that you back your arguments with proof.
  • Limited Coverage: This cash buyer caters to home sellers in Milwaukee.

Best Alternatives to Cream City Home Buyers

Even if you want to sell your house fast for cash, look for some alternatives better than Cream City Home Buyers. We’ve listed three below:

  • Houzeo: Houzeo is one of the best FSBO websites in America that lets you list your home on the MLS in just 24 to 48 hours. Here, multiple national and local cash home buyers make offers on your property, driving up its price. You can even get 100% of your home’s FMV.
  • Opendoor: Opendoor is the largest iBuyer in America extending cash offers for homes needing minimal repairs. They generally pay 70% to 80% of your home’s FMV but deduct a 5% service fee, closing costs, and repair costs from the offer.
  • HomeVestors: HomeVestors is a cash home buyer franchise offering 50% to 70% of the home’s FMV. However, they may deduct repair costs at closing. Further, since each office is independently owned, you won’t get consistent service across the country.

“We Buy Houses for Cash” Companies Near Me

There are other “We Buy Houses As Is” companies in the market. You can request an offer from multiple cash companies and pick the one that suits you the best.

RegionStates/CitiesCompanies That Buy Houses For Cash Near Me
NortheastStatesConnecticut | Maine | Massachusetts | New Hampshire | New Jersey | New York | Pennsylvania | Rhode Island | Vermont
NortheastKey CitiesBoston, MA | Brooklyn, NY | Buffalo, NY | Long Island, NY | New York City, NY | Philadelphia, PA | Pittsburgh, PA | Rochester, NY | York, PA | Clayton, NY
MidwestStatesIllinois | Indiana | Iowa | Kansas | Michigan | Minnesota | Missouri | Nebraska | North Dakota | Ohio | South Dakota | Wisconsin
MidwestKey CitiesCincinnati, OH | Cleveland, OH | Columbus, OH | Detroit, MI | Indianapolis, IN | Kansas City, MO | Milwaukee, WI | Omaha, NE | Minneapolis, MN | Wayne County, MI | St. Louis, MO | Boulevard Heights, MO |
SouthStatesAlabama | Arkansas | Delaware | Florida | Georgia | Kentucky | Louisiana | Maryland | Mississippi | North Carolina | Oklahoma | South Carolina | Tennessee | Texas | Virginia | Washington, D.C | West Virginia
SouthKey CitiesAtlanta, GA | Asheville, NC | Baltimore, MD | Charlotte, NC | Charleston, SC | Columbia, SC | Dallas, TX | Fort Lauderdale, FL | Fort Myers, FL | Fort Worth, TX | Greensboro, NC | Greenville, SC | Houston, TX | Huntsville, AL|Killeen, TX | Knoxville, TN | Lexington, KY | Louisville, KY | Miami, FL | Nashville, TN | New Orleans, LA | Orlando, FL | Pasadena, TX | Raleigh, NC | Rockville, MD | San Antonio, TX | St. Augustine, FL | Tampa, FL | West Palm Beach, FL | Memphis, TN | Austin, TX | Norfolk, VA | Jacksonville, FL | Tallahassee, FL | Pensacola, FL | Sarasota, FL | Panama City, FL | Augusta, GA | Virginia Beach, VA | Clearwater, FL | Savannah, GA | Chattanooga, TN | Columbus, GA | Lawrenceville, GA | Winston-Salem, NC | Birmingham, AL | Jackson, MS | Biloxi, MS
WestStatesAlaska | Arizona | California | Colorado | Hawaii | Idaho | Montana | Nevada | New Mexico | Oregon | Utah | Washington | Wyoming
WestKey CitiesColorado Springs, CO | Denver, CO | Fresno, CA | Las Vegas, NV | Los Angeles, CA | Phoenix, AZ | Sacramento, CA | San Diego, CA | San Francisco, CA | Seattle, WA | Tucson, AZ | Portland, OR | Salt Lake City, UT | Orange County, CA | Roseville, CA | Ventura, CA | Lemon Grove, CA | Casitas Springs, CA | Bakersfield, CA

📞 Need Help? Schedule a FREE Consultation


A Houzeo expert can answer all your questions regarding our technology.


Book a FREE Call

 

Frequently Asked Questions About Cream City Home Buyers

1. Is Cream City Home Buyers legit?

Yes, Cream City Home Buyers is a legitimate company founded in 2015. They buy houses for cash in Milwaukee.

Companies That Buy Houses for Cash Near Me 🔍

RegionCash Home Buyers
Nationwide Connect Home Buyers | ASAP Cash Offer | Expert Home Offers | House Buyer Network | Swift Homes | Fast Home Offer
Near-Nationwide Homevestors | We Buy Houses | Express Homebuyers| House Cashin | Highest Cash Offer
Northeast I Buy Li | IPS | ibuy585.com | Integrity First Home Buyers| Handsome Homebuyer | New England Home Buyers | Sell Fast Boston | Sell Now Homebuyers | First Choice Home Buyers | 1-800-cash Offer | Halo Homebuyers | Morgan Home Solutions | Sell to Jim | Snappy Home Buyers
MidwestDirect Home Buyers | I Buy SD | Ben Buys Indy Houses | Grandview Homes | Heartland Buys Houses | Christopher Ellyn Homes | Des Moines Home Buyers LLC | Professional Home Buyers | HouseMax | Jay Buys Detroit | Detroit Cash for Homes | Detroit Fair Offer | Minnesota Home Guys | Chris Buys Homes | Upward Home Solutions | Ohio Cash Buyers | All Ohio Home Buyers | Omaha Homes for Cash | Metro Milwaukee Home Buyer | Cream City Home Buyers
SouthCava Buys | Simply Sold | Homego | Irby Buys | Mark Spain Real Estate | 365 Property Buyers | Florida Cash Home Buyers | Quick Home Buyers | Freedom Cash Home Buyers | Sarasota Home Buyers | Maximum Cash Home Buyers | Cash Offer Kentucky | Geaux Home Buyers Llc | The Buy Guys | Maryland Cash House Buyers | Keen Home Buyers | Nc Cash Home Buyers | W Properties | Charleston House Buyers | New Horizon Home Buyers | Sell to Bobby | House Heroes | Traction Home Offer | Pps House Buyers | Investment Capital Home Buyers | MarketPro HomeBuyers | Texas All Cash Home Buyers | 4 Brothers Buy Houses | Advantage Homebuyers of America
WestTarek Buys | Osborne Homes | Property Max | Seller's Advantage | Sundae | Andrew The Home Buyer | Doug Hopkins Real Estate | John Buys Bay Area Houses | Laurel Buys Houses | John Medina Buys Houses | SoCal Home Buyers | Sell Quick California | Gordon Buys Homes | The Buy-Out Company | Oahu Home Buyers | Khd Real Estate LLC | Enlight Homebuyers | We Buy Any Vegas House | Boise House Buyers | Brothers buy homes | House Buyers of America | The Easy Home Buyer | I Will Buy House | Beachworks LLC

Write a Review

Please give a rating

Your name is required
Write a comment
Reviews
0
(0 Reviews)
Cream City Home Buyers Real Estate Reviews

Save $20

On Silver & up plans

Use Coupon Code:

Copied
Need help? Call us on
(844) 448-0110